Game Rankings: Every Review Scored & Compared

Every review published on the site, side by side, sorted by score so it’s easy to see how titles stack up against each other. Filter by platform to compare within a single console or PC, or leave it on All to see the full field at once.

Every score comes from the review itself — nothing here is re-averaged or adjusted after the fact, so the ranking reflects each title’s original verdict exactly. Scores run on a 0–10 scale, and the table highlights three bands: a Platinum tier for anything scoring 9.3 or higher, a Gold tier from 8.5 up, and a Silver tier for everything scoring below that. A high Silver-tier score is still a strong recommendation; the tiers exist to make it faster to spot the small handful of titles that cleared the highest bar, not to suggest anything below Gold is a poor game.

The Classic filter groups reviews of older-generation titles — games reviewed on hardware like the Xbox 360 rather than the current console lineup — alongside the current-gen PS5, Xbox Series X, Switch and PC filters. That keeps a stand-out older review from getting buried under a wave of new releases, while still letting anyone comparing only current-gen titles filter it out entirely.

The rank column updates automatically as new reviews are added, so a title’s position here can shift over time even though its own score never changes after publication. Anyone who only cares about one platform can jump straight to that hub page instead — the ranking here is the cross-platform view, useful for settling which system is putting out the strongest lineup at any given point rather than judging a single console in isolation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How is the Game Rankings table sorted?

By review score, highest first, pulling the score directly from each review’s own verdict. Nothing is re-averaged or adjusted after publication.

What do the Platinum, Gold and Silver tiers mean?

Platinum covers scores of 9.3 and above, Gold starts at 8.5, and Silver is everything below that. They’re a visual shortcut for spotting the very highest scorers, not a judgment that a Silver-tier game is weak.

What does the “Classic” platform filter include?

Reviews of games on older, non-current-gen hardware, kept in the same table as PS5, Xbox Series X, Switch and PC so a strong older-generation review isn’t dropped from the comparison entirely.

Can I compare scores within just one platform?

Yes. The filter buttons above the table narrow it down to a single platform — PS5, Xbox Series X, Switch, PC or Classic — while leaving it on All shows the full field ranked together.

Every Review, Ranked

Games ranked by review score, highest first
Rank Score Game Platform Reviewed
#1 9.5 Baldur’s Gate 3 Review: Larian’s RPG Still Holds Up PC Jun 2026
#2 9.5 Astro Bot Review PS5 Jul 2026
#3 9.5 Bastion Review Xbox 360 Jul 2011
#4 9.5 The Alliance Alive – Review Archive Apr 2018
#5 9 Death Stranding 2 Review PS5 Jul 2026
#6 9 Silent Hill 2 Remake Review PS5 Jul 2026
#7 9 Indiana Jones and the Great Circle Review Xbox Series X Aug 2026
#8 9 Alan Wake Review Xbox 360 May 2010
#9 9 Battlefield 1943 Jul 2009
#10 9 The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings – Enhanced Edition – Review Apr 2012
#11 9 Need for Speed Most Wanted (2012) – Review Nov 2012
#12 9 Homefront – Review Mar 2011
#13 8.7 Black Myth: Wukong Review PC Jun 2026
#14 8.5 Helldivers 2 Review PC Jun 2026
#15 8.5 Halo Infinite Review – Xbox Series X Campaign & Multiplayer Xbox Series X Jul 2026
#16 8.5 Gurumin 3D : A Monstrous Adventure – Review Archive Oct 2017
#17 8.5 Battlefield Bad Company 2 – Review Mar 2010
#18 8 The Banner Saga Trilogy – Review Archive Dec 2018
#19 8 Creeping Terror – Review Archive Aug 2018
#20 8 WWE ’13 – Review Oct 2012
#21 7.5 Princess Peach: Showtime! Review: A Charming Switch Exclusive Switch Jul 2026
#22 7.5 Two Worlds II – Review Feb 2011
#23 7 Crash Time Jun 2009
#24 7 Sacred 2: Fallen Angel – Reviewed Jun 2009
#25 6.5 Psychedelica of the Ashen Hawk – Review Archive Oct 2019
#26 6.5 Ninja Gaiden 3 – Review Apr 2012
#27 6 Bad Apple Wars – Review Archive Aug 2018
#28 6 Alpha Protocol – Review Jun 2010